← All houses Ongoing · Four years in

The Oak House

An off-market house nobody else wanted, untouched since 1980, and the one they came back for.

Living room seen from above: layered rug, round table, woven chairs and a ship painting

Caleb found this house off-market, and we couldn't wait to see it.

The excitement lasted about five minutes.

It hadn't been renovated since it was built in 1980. Every room needed work. There were red carpets in the bathrooms, and so much stuff inside that it was hard to even picture the home underneath it all.

We walked away convinced it was just too much.

But we couldn't shake it.

We were completely in love with the neighborhood, and we believed that with enough vision, and a whole lot of hard work, any house could become a home. We had also just finished flipping our previous house, and the equity from that gave us the chance to dream a little bigger.

A few months later, we checked to see if it had sold.

It hadn't. So we took the leap.

Four years later, this house looks completely different. But that's not my favorite part.

My favorite part is that it's become the backdrop for our life together. We've welcomed babies home here, celebrated birthdays and holidays, hosted friends around our table, and watched this house slowly become our home.

Looking back, I'm so thankful we came back for one more tour.

Shelby

The house now

Room by room, over four years.

Kitchen island in honed stone with fluted pendants and leather stools
The kitchen

White oak, and stone with a little movement.

Rift oak cabinetry, a plaster hood built to the room rather than bought, and counters chosen for veining instead of uniformity. Unlacquered brass on the faucet, left to darken.

The island seats five because the table only seats six, and everybody stands in here anyway.

Study with deep green built-in shelves, an upright piano and a globe
The study

Green to the ceiling, on purpose.

Walls, shelves, cabinets and ceiling all in one color, so the room reads as a single enclosed thing instead of four walls with furniture against them.

The books are the ones they actually read. The pottery, the globe, the landscape painting on the shelf, all found one at a time.

Playroom with woven pendants, climbing frame, play tent and a wall of books
The playroom

A room for them that adults can sit in.

Woven pendants, a wool rug, and storage low enough that the children can actually put things away. Toys in natural wood and canvas rather than plastic, so the room reads calm even when it is a mess.

Staircase gallery wall of vintage oil paintings and framed prints
Shelby hanging a small antique portrait beside a plaster archway
The small things

Where the house actually lives.

Trailing plant and an antique clock on a brass tray, on a walnut shelf
A tray, a clock, a plant that trails. Nothing here was bought as a set.
Spice drawer with labelled glass jars and wooden lids
The spice drawer. Order counts as decorating when you open it daily.
Entry bench with kilim upholstery, gold framed paintings and garland on the stair rail
The entry at Christmas, which is when the house is most itself.
Elsewhere in the house

Still being added to.

Plaster archway with vintage seascape paintings and wide plank oak floors
A plaster arch, softened at the corners so it looks original.
Bathroom vanity in quartzite with wall mounted brass taps and an antique portrait
Quartzite run up the wall, and a portrait where a mirror would be obvious.
Shower with fluted geometric tile, stone bench and unlacquered brass fittings
Fluted tile laid in a pattern instead of straight courses.
Walk-in pantry with checkerboard floor, oak cabinetry and open shelving
Checkerboard in the pantry. The room nobody sees gets the boldest floor.
Breakfast nook with a live edge table, built-in banquette and magnolia branches
The banquette is built in, so the table seats whoever turns up.
Bedroom with deep brown walls, an iron bed and a brass sconce
Brown walls in the main bedroom. Dark rooms sleep better than white ones.

Follow the process

@shelbynicoleraney  ·  new decisions every week

View Instagram